Matthew 1: 18-25
Matthew’s telling of the birth of Jesus is very, very different from Luke’s. We’re accustomed to blending the two stories together. So, we have our nativities and pageants with shepherds arriving at a stable—followed by the wise men. All are there together.
But the two gospels are very different. We lose something when we so readily and easily combine the stories. Luke focuses on Mary. Matthew focuses on Joseph. In Luke, angels appear – first one comes to Mary, then a multitude appear to the shepherds in the fields. Joseph is almost an afterthought in Luke’s account. Here, in Matthew’s story, he is central.
“Now the birth of Jesus the Messiah took place in this way. When his mother Mary had been engaged to Joseph, but before they lived together, she was found to be with child from the Holy Spirit. Her husband Joseph, being a righteous man and unwilling to expose her to public disgrace, planned to dismiss her quietly.”
Joseph was a righteous man. He lived his life according to the tradition that he had been taught and according to the laws of his community. He was a man of faith. Yet, according to the law, handed down from generation to generation, righteousness demanded that Mary be put to death. She was found to be with child. We know, from the storyteller, that the child was from the Holy Spirit. But, Joseph couldn’t have known that. She had, by all appearances, sinned greatly. The law, God’s law, said she should be put to death.
“Joseph being a righteous man and unwilling to expose her to public disgrace, resolved to dismiss her quietly.”
The law said that he should have her put to death. Now, scholars note that by Joseph’s time women were seldom put do death. But, instead, it was common to have a public dismissal. It would have been a way for Joseph to publicly declare that he had remained righteous, he had upheld God’s law. Publicly disgracing Mary was a way of fulfilling the strict requirements of that law.
But, we’re told, Joseph was unwilling to expose her to public disgrace – so he resolved to dismiss her quietly.
Without the public dismissal, Joseph may have been tainted as Mary certainly would have been. Strictly speaking, therefore, his decision to dismiss her quietly meant that he was willing to break with the tradition. He was giving the community a reason to question his own righteousness. We glimpse, in this little snippet, compassion. Joseph had compassion for Mary. She was in a position for which there was no good outcome. His compassion for her meant that although he couldn’t turn his back completely on God’s law as he knew it, he would not take part in carrying out that law in ways that further hurt her.
We hear a lot today about the loss of morality, the slipping of values. Strident voices tell us that we need to get back to the ways of the past, the morality that once guided the majority of the people. There are those pushing for laws that will force people into their understanding of what “righteousness” and “morality” looks like. And, more often than not, these strident voices call themselves Christian. They rail against practices and attitudes that, to them, are incompatible with their understanding of what faith is. They push for laws that reflect their values.
What’s missing, too often, is compassion. Yes, there is talk about being concerned about the “souls” of those who are not living as others think they should. But real compassion is lacking.
This season is a reminder that God’s salvation came not as a new law book, a new codified morality. God’s salvation came as a person. After Joseph had decided to dismiss Mary, an angel – a messenger from God – appeared to him in a dream. “Do not be afraid to take Mary as your wife…She will bear a son“Do not be afraid to take Mary as your wife…She will bear a son, and you are to name him Jesus…This took place to fulfill what had been spoken by the Lord through the prophet: Look, the virgin shall conceive and bear a son, and they shall name him Emmanuel, which means, God is with us.”
Joseph was a righteous man. His righteousness was rooted in the law – yet the law was tempered by compassion. And in seeking to be compassionate, he more fully demonstrated what righteousness is.
“Show us the Father and we will be satisfied,” Philip said to Jesus one time. “If you have seen me, you have seen the Father,” Jesus replied. When a specialist in the law asked Jesus what the greatest commandment was, Jesus answered, “You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart, and with all your soul, and with all your mind. This is the greatest and first commandment. And a second is like it: You shall love your neighbor as yourself. On these two commandments hang all the law and the prophets.”
The law is a gift intended to lead us toward that love – toward compassion that sees and acknowledges other people. I read a blurb this week about an interview with a politician who has worked against giving women the freedom to choose for themselves when it comes to abortion. A reporter asked him, “What do you think makes a woman want to have an abortion. He paused. Then he said,, “Well, there’s probably a lot of reas— I’m not a woman.” He laughed. “I’m thinking now if I’m a woman why would I want to get … Some of it has to do with economics. A lot of it has to do with economics. I don’t know. It’s a question I’ve never even thought about.”
It’s a question he never thought about. There was no compassion in his zeal to create laws that restrict the freedom of women to make decisions for themselves and their loved ones. The news this week has had the horrifying stories of Aleppo. Many have noted that our own nation’s choice to distance itself from the suffering there has contributed to the chaos –and the tragedy that continues to unfold. “Not our problem,” we might say. But God’s righteousness does not allow us to set limits on who our neighbors are. In Luke’s telling of the encounter between Jesus and the lawyer, the story of the Good Samaritan follows. An outsider, a despised outsider, provided the example of what it means to love one’s neighbor.
How might it change the discourse in our nation, in our cities and our communities if we seek that righteousness that Joseph demonstrated? I read about another politician who changed his views on choice after he listened to women’s stories.
There are so many spheres of modern life that need the righteousness that is based on compassion --- on the desire to see and hear the stories of those who struggle, of those who are often on the receiving end of harsh judgements. We need to listen to those who cry out –and even to those who have no voice. At times, like Joseph, it may seem that the path of compassion conflicts with God’s law. But Jesus reminded those around him, and teaches us, that the deepest, the fullest observance of God’s law sees, hears, and cares for and about our neighbors, whoever they might be. We need to hear the voices of women who see no other choice. We need to hear from those who cry desperately for us to acknowledge that Black lives matter. In this season, when we remember the stories of Jesus’ birth and childhood, we should certainly be attentive to the plight of refugees.
When we say that someone is righteous in our culture we tend to think more along the lines of “self-righteous.” Jesus condemned the Pharisees when their observances of the law became self-centered and so rule centered that they lost the ability to have compassion for others. They no longer connected. Joseph gives us a different image of righteousness. It was based on the law – but that law led him to a relationship with God that allowed him to “break” the law by taking Mary as his wife and accepting the child as his own – which he did when he named him.
Martin Luther said, “Sin boldly.” I think this story of Joseph tells us the same thing. When compassion and law seem to be at odds with one another, we err on the side of compassion. We live by faith – we seek to be grounded in the ways of God. Ultimately, that calls us to be known by love.
When God’s Plans Aren’t Ours
James 5:7-10, Matthew 11:2-11
One of my favorite movies is Mr. Holland’s Opus. It tells the story of a musician who planned a great career. He expected to be renowned as a performer and a composer. In the meantime, to make ends meet, he took a job teaching music in high school. And there he stayed – for decades – feeling that he had wasted his life. None of his dreams had come true.
This morning’s gospel lesson gives us a disappointed John the Baptist. He was in prison. This outspoken man had promised that the Messiah was about to appear. And that promise had been heard with joy by those who were waiting eagerly for God’s realm to come – in earthly power. They, like John, wanted a new King David who would roust their enemies and set things right once again. John had been the “voice of one crying out in the wilderness, ‘Prepare the way of the Lord. Make his paths straight.’” He spoke of repentance. He called for justice, for living in ways that would bear the good fruit of God’s promised realm. He baptized with water, but spoke of the one who would come and baptize with Holy Spirit – and purifying fire! His was a campaign speech that excited his hearers – that promised a better day.
Of course, his talk about a new realm did not sit well with Herod. So, John found himself in prison. Maybe he thought that Jesus would pick up the refrain and launch the revolt. But, Jesus’ ministry was not like John’s ministry. Yes, he drew crowds – but he didn’t fire them up in the same way that John had. There didn’t seem to be a new realm about to break forth, a realm that would dismantle the powers that oppressed. So John was questioning – questioning his own message, his own role in proclaiming God’s presence. Jesus’ ministry did not seem to be the fulfillment of his message. So, he wondered, “Are you the one who is to come, or are we to wait for another?”
I heard one of the early feminist theologians, Rosemary Radford Ruether, speak, years ago. She said that we have been accustomed to thinking of history as a straight line. If that’s the way we look at history, maybe it’s the way we understand life, as well. We expect things to move forward in an orderly fashion. So we make plans. We have expectations and dreams.
But, we know, things don’t always work out as we might have expected. Dreams and expectations are challenged – and sometimes shattered. It is a sobering experience that might, at times, leave us questioning whether or not God is present. Where is God when the path toward increasing justice is suddenly blocked? Where is God when the vulnerable are threatened? Where is God when our personal dreams and hopes falter?
Where is God when our personal hopes and dreams falter?
John the Baptist had hope – hope that he was part of ushering in God’s promised realm. And he didn’t see it appearing. Jesus wasn’t leading the revolution that would re-establish Israel as a free nation.
Ruether said that we need to get away from seeing history (and the human story) as a straight line. She drew the straight line on the blackboard. Then she drew, what she said, was the more realistic way that the human story unfolds. It was a spiral. (A Slinky!)
Perhaps, in that spiral there is grace. Jesus said no one had been born who was greater than John the Baptist. Yet, even the least in the God's realm were greater. John had proclaimed God's realm. Yet, even this great proclaimer could not understand it fully! So, he heard what Jesus was doing – but couldn’t see that Jesus’ ministry was the very fulfillment of what he had proclaimed. John hoped, as did most of Israel, for a mighty warrior. The one who came was the Prince of Peace. Jesus recognized that the goal of God’s realm present on earth was not to be achieved with a straight line game plan, conquering those who disagreed, but by sowing the seeds that would take root and bring the multitudes into alignment with the ways of God.
Whenever our straight line scenarios get disrupted, maybe we’re invited to look again – and see God at work. It has been true, throughout history, that human beings seek power people who will make things right. We still look for messiahs who promise us everything so that we will follow and find the world living up to our dreams and expectations. Every once in a while, someone emerges, someone who embodies the ways and values of God – speaks to them and works for them. But ore often than not, the way is hard. The world is not comfortable with the message. And, we are still disappointed.
If only they had the power! But the way of power always falls short. We can’t force God’s ways on the world, on others. We can’t legislate it. We can’t demand it.
But, we can live God's ways. We can live as an invitation to others to participate in God’s realm—always, ever within reach. We can choose love when others choose hate. “Love your enemies.”
“Tell John what you hear and see; the blind receive their sight, the lame walk, the lepers are cleansed, the deaf hear, the dead are raised, and the poor have good news brought to them.” God’s realm was at hand – just not in the way John had expected it. The good news was emerging in lives changed and in community restored.
It still emerges that way. It is around us when people stand up to bullies and racists. It’s around us when the hungry are fed, when those who struggle are given a fair chance and the help that they need. It is around us when those who are different or fearful are welcomed and given safe shelter. It’s around us when we recognize that our own visions of God’s realm are always partial – and that a fuller vision emerges as more and more voices are heard.
It struck me, as I was looking back at the story of Mr. Holland’s Opus, that the movie was really another telling of “It’s a Wonderful Life” – without Christmas or an angel trying to earn his wings. Mr. Holland struggled with his failed dreams, with a life that didn’t meet his expectations. When the school eliminated his position, many of his former students gathered to surprise him – playing in a band and performing his “opus.” He found, as did George Bailey, that he had lived his dream – just not in the way he had expected. With and through his students, he made music – he was a performer. His dream of being a composer came true in the impact he had on students’ lives – giving them confidence to go out into the world and make a difference.
In the spiral there is grace. Straight lines tend to leave people on the margins. A few take the power and others are silenced. In the spiral, we look again – and seek a way forward that bends toward that God promised realm that is marked by justice and mercy for an ever widening circle of people. The Messiah came. He showed John, the crowds, his disciples and us that God comes not as a conquering warrior, but as a presence born among us and within us, to transform our lives and the world.
Jesus said that John the Baptist was great – yet the least in God’s realm was greater than he. It is a reminder that all of us are invited to bear witness to God’s realm in our words and in our deeds. If the world disappoints us, if it seems that it has fallen short of what we expect, we could examine our expectations. Have we left room for God’s agenda? Where is God at work? Through whom is God at work? Is there a role we can play in preparing God’s way?
Christmas Eve Service
Proudly powered by Weebly
Weekly Worship Services
We continue to be mindful of the dangers of this pandemic, so we are not having in person worship services. You may join us on Facebook each week , Sunday morning at 10:30 AM, or watch the service later on Facebook. The services are also connected to this website by sometime on Monday in the worship section.